Skip to content

Home / Guides / Content strategy

Content strategy

Keep, refresh or retire? Give old content a proper review

How I review older content using evidence per page, with clear choices and reversible actions instead of deleting everything before a date.

By Shane Rounce · 2 min read

“Delete everything older than this date” is a wonderfully simple rule. It is also a fairly poor substitute for finding out what those pages still do.

I use age to choose a review queue, then assess each page’s current purpose, search activity, visits and useful links. From there I can decide whether to keep it, update it, combine it with a better page or retire it carefully.

Start with the job the page still does

I look at search activity, visits where available, useful links and the content itself. An old explanation may still answer a recurring question. A time-sensitive announcement may now need an archive notice. Several near-duplicates may be better served by one carefully maintained page.

A quiet reporting window does not prove that an article has no value. Seasonal demand, missing analytics and incomplete backlink information all affect the evidence. “No useful data yet” is a more honest label than “worthless”.

Make the choices easy to understand

Keep
The page still serves a useful purpose. Keep its facts and links under review.
Needs an update
There is a reason to revisit the content, its presentation or its promise in search.
Consider combining
Read the overlap, choose a proper replacement if one exists and plan any redirect.
Keep out of search
The page may remain useful to visitors without being intended as a search landing page.
Retire
If the content has gone, use an appropriate response and explain the decision.

Those are editorial decisions. A report can suggest a review group; it cannot know that an unrelated destination is a suitable replacement just because it has more traffic.

Separate the recommendation from the action

Keep recommendations separate from actions. Before applying a redirect, indexing instruction, old-article notice or gone response, record the intended effect and how to undo it. Preserve the source content while reviewing the result, and make the action history easy to inspect.

A notice is not the same as a search instruction. A redirect is not the same as deleting a database record. Clear labels matter because otherwise someone can approve a small-sounding change without understanding what a visitor will receive.

Review a small batch first

I start with representative examples, check their actual public responses and confirm that internal links and sitemaps still make sense. Then I review the data over an appropriate period. For pages being kept out of search, I also check that crawl rules allow the indexing instruction to be seen.

For a longer-term policy, I agree which content expires and which needs periodic care. That is much more useful than returning every few years with a bigger deletion list.

The aim is a smaller maintenance burden and a clearer experience for readers. Keeping useful work is part of that job.

If an article used to perform better, I first investigate the decline before choosing an action. That review separates missing evidence, seasonal changes and problems with the page, with a worksheet for recording the decision.

Need a hand with your next project?

I help with SEO, with practical advice and hands-on work. Tell me what you are trying to improve.

Email Shane